| Primary | ||||
| Name | P | BF-RL | BF-DMB | Usage |
| Robin Roberts | sp | 512 | 186 | 36 |
| Wilmer Mizell | sp | 437 | 292 | 67 |
| Jim Kaat | sp | 865 | 1000 | 116 |
| Jack Kralick | sp | 1023 | 983 | 96 |
| Juan Pizarro | sp | 832 | 862 | 104 |
| Hal Brown | sp | 668 | 663 | 99 |
| Jim Bunning | sp | 1110 | 1123 | 101 |
| Howie Nunn | mr | 170 | 111 | 65 |
| Tom Morgan | mr | 363 | 241 | 66 |
| Johnny James | mr | 334 | 245 | 73 |
| Tex Clevenger | mr | 218 | 156 | 72 |
| Ray Moore | cl | 255 | 185 | 73 |
| Total | 6787 | 6047 | 0 | |