5/10/1940, ROC40-OTS40, Comiskey Park
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 R H E LOB DP
1940 Arsenal 7 3 0 2 2 0 0 1 5 20 27 1 13 0
1940 Monsters 1 1 0 3 1 4 0 0 0 10 13 0 14 3
Arsenal AB R H BI AVG Monsters AB R H BI AVG
Hack 3b 7 2 4 4 .385 Moore,JJ lf 1 1 0 0 .288
Keller cf 6 1 3 1 .253 Hoag ph 3 0 0 0 .250
Selkirk rf 5 2 4 1 .348 Whitehead,B 3b 5 3 4 1 .288
Page p 1 0 1 0 .333 Koy cf 4 1 2 2 .336
Greenberg lf 6 3 3 3 .348 Gustine ph 1 0 0 0 .319
Herman,Bi 2b 7 2 4 0 .333 York 1b 4 1 1 1 .239
Gantenbein 1b 5 2 2 3 .286 Ross,C rf 3 1 1 2 .319
Warren c 5 3 3 1 .175 Schultz c 3 0 0 0 .188
Webb ss 1 3 1 2 .235 Frye p 3 0 1 1 .500
Auker p 4 1 1 2 .188 Mueller,H 2b 3 1 2 1 .216
Niggeling p 1 0 0 0 .000 Knickerbocker ss 4 1 1 1 .333
Solters rf 1 1 1 2 .327 Kramer p 0 0 0 0 .000
49 20 27 19 Mattick ph 1 1 1 0 .222
Tebbetts c 1 0 0 1 .264
36 10 13 10
Arsenal INN H R ER BB K PCH STR ERA
Auker W 3-2 5.0 10 10 8 7 0 124 69 3.45
Niggeling H 1 2.1 2 0 0 1 2 39 19 3.12
Page 1.2 1 0 0 2 2 27 15 2.70
9.0 13 10 8 10 4 190 103
Monsters INN H R ER BB K PCH STR ERA
Kramer L 0-1 4.0 13 12 12 5 1 99 55 11.30
Frye 5.0 14 8 8 4 3 128 74 7.63
9.0 27 20 20 9 4 227 129
ROC: Solters inserted at rf in the 8th
OTS: Mattick batted for Kramer in the 4th
Tebbetts inserted at c in the 5th
Hoag batted for Moore,JJ in the 5th
Hoag moved to lf in the 6th
Gustine batted for Koy in the 9th
E-Hack. 2B-Hack 2, Greenberg, Herman,Bi, Koy 2, Mueller,H. 3B-Warren, Auker.
HR-Gantenbein(2). SB-Keller(2). K-Hack, Keller, Gantenbein, Auker, York,
Knickerbocker, Frye 2. BB-Keller, Selkirk, Gantenbein 2, Warren, Webb 4,
Moore,JJ 2, Whitehead,B, York 2, Ross,C 2, Mueller,H, Kramer, Tebbetts.
SF-Greenberg, Webb, Koy, Ross,C, Mueller,H, Knickerbocker, Tebbetts.
PB-Tebbetts. WP-Niggeling, Kramer 2.
GWRBI: Greenberg
Temperature: 69, Sky: partly cloudy, Wind: right to left at 13 MPH.
5/10/1940, ROC40-OTS40, Comiskey Park
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 R H E LOB DP
1940 Arsenal 7 3 0 2 2 0 0 1 5 20 27 1 13 0
1940 Monsters 1 1 0 3 1 4 0 0 0 10 13 0 14 3
Arsenal -----A------ -----B------ -----C------ -----D------ -----E------
Hack 3b 1>5/fl D.3-H 13 S.3-H;1-2 6>k
Keller cf S 63 3>8 S.2-H;1-3 W
Selkirk rf SB2 2>S W 54/f S.1-2
S.2-3
Page p
Greenberg lf S.3-H;1-2 wp.1-2 wp.1-2 5>Frye 543/gdp
D.2-H 31.2-3 S
Herman,Bi 2b 5/L S.2-3 7 D.1-3 7>S
Gantenbein 1b HR.2-H;1-H W.1-2 4>8 IW 8
Warren c S note 1 T note 2 9
Webb ss W.1-2 7/SF.3-H IW S.3-H W.1-2
Auker p T.2-H;1-H 8 k 8
Niggeling p 5/fl
Solters rf
1: W.3-H;2-3;1-2 2: 643/gdp.3-H;2-3
Monsters -----A------ -----B------ -----C------ -----D------ -----E------
Moore,JJ lf 1>W W.2-3;1-2 e5.1-2;B-1
Hoag ph 53 7>53
Whitehead,B 3b 46/f.B-1 note 1 S.2-3;1-2 6>W S
Koy cf D.1-H 5 note 2 D.1-3 9
Gustine ph
York 1b 43.2-3 64/f S.3-H;1-3 IW wp.1-2
k
Ross,C rf W 3>63 7/SF.3-H note 3 8>S
Schultz c 43 8 6/L
Frye p note 4 k
Mueller,H 2b 2>3 S 5>D Niggeling W.1-2
note 5
Knickerbocker ss S 54/f 9.2-3 8/SF.3-H Page
k
Kramer p W.1-2
Mattick ph 4>S
Tebbetts c 8/SF.3-H 63 W.2-3;1-2
1: S.3-H;2-3;1-2 2: 9/SF.3-H;2-3 3: W.3-H;2-3;1-2 4: S.3-H;2-3;1-2
5: 8/SF.3-H;2-3
Arsenal -----F------ -----G------ -----H------ -----I------ -----J------
Hack 3b 8>S D.2-H;1-H
Keller cf S.1-2 k
Selkirk rf S.2-H;1-2
Page p S.2-3
Greenberg lf note 1 7/SF.3-H
Herman,Bi 2b 53 pb.1-2
S.2-3
Gantenbein 1b 9>S k
Warren c S.1-2
Webb ss W.2-3;1-2
Auker p
Niggeling p
Solters rf note 2
1: 643/gdp.2-3 2: S.3-H;2-H;1-2
Monsters -----F------ -----G------ -----H------ -----I------ -----J------
Moore,JJ lf
Hoag ph 64/f
Whitehead,B 3b 9>S
Koy cf
Gustine ph 8
York 1b W.1-2
Ross,C rf 53.2-3;1-2
Schultz c
Frye p k
Mueller,H 2b
Knickerbocker ss
Kramer p
Mattick ph
Tebbetts c
Arsenal IN OUT ER Monsters IN OUT ER
Auker A1 D6 8 W 3-2 Kramer A1 D3 12 L 0-1
Niggeling D7 E7 0 H 1 Frye D4 G6 8
Page E8 F6 0
5/10/1940, ROC40-OTS40, Comiskey Park
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 R H E LOB DP
1940 Arsenal 7 3 0 2 2 0 0 1 5 20 27 1 13 0
1940 Monsters 1 1 0 3 1 4 0 0 0 10 13 0 14 3
Score O Rnr BS Event
----- - --- -- -----
************** Top of the 1st inning, Arsenal batting
0-0 0 --- 11 Hack popped out to third (FBX)
0-0 1 --- 31 Keller grounded a single between third and short (CBBBX)
0-0 1 1-- 10 Keller stole second (B1>S)
0-0 1 -2- 12 Selkirk lined a single to left, Keller to third (B1>S.SX)
0-0 1 1-3 10 Greenberg grounded a single up the middle, Keller scored,
Selkirk to second (BX)
1-0 1 12- 01 Herman,Bi lined out to third (FX)
1-0 2 12- 10 Gantenbein homered deep to right center, Selkirk scored,
Greenberg scored (BX)
4-0 2 --- 11 Warren reached on an infield single to third (CBX)
4-0 2 1-- 32 Webb walked, Warren to second (BCFBB>B)
4-0 2 12- 10 Auker tripled deep to center, Warren scored, Webb scored
(BX)
6-0 2 --3 10 Hack lined a double to left center, Auker scored (BX)
7-0 2 -2- 11 Keller grounded out to short (FBX)
************** Bottom of the 1st inning, Monsters batting
7-0 0 --- 31 Moore,JJ walked (BCBBB)
7-0 0 1-- 02 Whitehead,B grounded to second, forcing Moore,JJ at
second, Whitehead,B to first (FCX)
7-0 1 1-- 00 Koy lined a double to left center, Whitehead,B scored (X)
7-1 1 -2- 22 York grounded out to second, Koy to third (BFBCX)
7-1 2 --3 32 Ross,C walked (CBSBBB)
7-1 2 1-3 00 Schultz grounded out to second (X)
************** Top of the 2nd inning, Arsenal batting
7-1 0 --- 00 Selkirk lined a single to shallow left (X)
7-1 0 1-- 00 Kramer threw a wild pitch, Selkirk to second (B)
7-1 0 -2- 12 Greenberg doubled to right center, Selkirk scored (B.CFX)
8-1 0 -2- 22 Herman,Bi grounded a single between first and second,
Greenberg to third (CBSBX)
8-1 0 1-3 32 Gantenbein walked, Herman,Bi to second (CBBFFBB)
8-1 0 123 32 Warren walked, Greenberg scored, Herman,Bi to third,
Gantenbein to second (BBBCFB)
9-1 0 123 01 Webb hit a sacrifice fly to left, Herman,Bi scored (FX)
10-1 1 12- 02 Auker flied out to center (CFX)
10-1 2 12- 10 Hack grounded out to the mound (BX)
************** Bottom of the 2nd inning, Monsters batting
10-1 0 --- 10 Mueller,H popped out to first (BX)
10-1 1 --- 11 Knickerbocker lined a single to shallow center (CBX)
10-1 1 1-- 32 Kramer walked, Knickerbocker to second (BFBBCFB)
10-1 1 12- 31 Moore,JJ walked, Knickerbocker to third, Kramer to second
(BFBBB)
10-1 1 123 01 Whitehead,B lined a single to shallow left, Knickerbocker
scored, Kramer to third, Moore,JJ to second (FX)
10-2 1 123 01 Koy popped out to third (CX)
10-2 2 123 00 York grounded to short, forcing Whitehead,B at second (X)
************** Top of the 3rd inning, Arsenal batting
10-2 0 --- 21 Keller lined out to center (BBCX)
10-2 1 --- 30 Selkirk walked (BBBB)
10-2 1 1-- 01 Kramer threw a wild pitch, Selkirk to second (CB)
10-2 1 -2- 11 Greenberg grounded out to first, Selkirk to third (CB.X)
10-2 2 --3 22 Herman,Bi popped out to left (CFBFFBX)
************** Bottom of the 3rd inning, Monsters batting
10-2 0 --- 01 Ross,C grounded out to short (CX)
10-2 1 --- 11 Schultz flied out to center (FBX)
10-2 2 --- 11 Mueller,H grounded a single between third and short (SBX)
10-2 2 1-- 12 Knickerbocker grounded to third, forcing Mueller,H at
second (CBCX)
************** Top of the 4th inning, Arsenal batting
10-2 0 --- 20 Gantenbein flied out to center (BBX)
10-2 1 --- 00 Warren tripled deep to right center (X)
10-2 1 --3 30 Webb was walked intentionally (IIII)
10-2 1 1-3 02 Auker struck out (FFFS)
10-2 2 1-3 00 Hack reached on an infield single to third, Warren
scored, Webb to second (X)
11-2 2 12- 10 Keller grounded a single up the middle, Webb scored, Hack
to third (BX)
12-2 2 1-3 10 Selkirk grounded to third, forcing Keller at second (BX)
************** Bottom of the 4th inning, Monsters batting
Mattick pinch hitting for Kramer
12-2 0 --- 22 Mattick grounded a single between first and second
(BFBFFX)
12-2 0 1-- 22 Mattick to second on an error by the third baseman Hack,
Moore,JJ to first (BCBFFX)
12-2 0 12- 21 Whitehead,B lined a single between first and second,
Mattick to third, Moore,JJ to second (BBFX)
12-2 0 123 22 Koy hit a sacrifice fly to right, Mattick scored,
Moore,JJ to third (FFBFFBFX)
12-3 1 1-3 11 York grounded a single between first and second, Moore,JJ
scored, Whitehead,B to third (BFX)
12-4 1 1-3 32 Ross,C hit a sacrifice fly to left, Whitehead,B scored
(BSBFBX)
12-5 2 1-- 21 Schultz lined out to short (BCBX)
************** Top of the 5th inning, Arsenal batting
Frye now pitching
Tebbetts now playing catcher
12-5 0 --- 10 Greenberg grounded a single between third and short (BX)
12-5 0 1-- 22 Herman,Bi lined a double down the third base line,
Greenberg to third (BBCFX)
12-5 0 -23 30 Gantenbein was walked intentionally (IIII)
12-5 0 123 10 Warren grounded into a double play, Knickerbocker to
Mueller,H to York, Greenberg scored, Herman,Bi to third
(BX)
13-5 2 --3 22 Webb grounded a single up the middle, Herman,Bi scored
(CFBBFX)
14-5 2 1-- 22 Auker flied out to center (BBCCX)
************** Bottom of the 5th inning, Monsters batting
14-5 0 --- 32 Mueller,H lined a double to right center (CFBBBX)
14-5 0 -2- 01 Knickerbocker flied out to right, Mueller,H to third (FX)
14-5 1 --3 02 Tebbetts hit a sacrifice fly to center, Mueller,H scored
(FFFX)
Hoag pinch hitting for Moore,JJ
14-6 2 --- 10 Hoag grounded out to third (BX)
************** Top of the 6th inning, Arsenal batting
Hoag moved to left field
14-6 0 --- 32 Hack struck out (FBFFBBS)
14-6 1 --- 32 Keller walked (BBFFBB)
14-6 1 1-- 10 Selkirk grounded a single up the middle, Keller to second
(BX)
14-6 1 12- 02 Greenberg grounded into a double play, Whitehead,B to
Mueller,H to York (CFX)
************** Bottom of the 6th inning, Monsters batting
14-6 0 --- 32 Whitehead,B walked (CBFBBB)
14-6 0 1-- 20 Koy lined a double to right center, Whitehead,B to third
(BBX)
14-6 0 -23 30 York was walked intentionally (IIII)
14-6 0 123 30 Ross,C walked, Whitehead,B scored, Koy to third, York to
second (BBBB)
14-7 0 123 00 Frye lined a single to shallow left, Koy scored, York to
third, Ross,C to second (X)
Niggeling now pitching
14-8 0 123 00 Mueller,H hit a sacrifice fly to center, York scored,
Ross,C to third (X)
14-9 1 1-3 32 Knickerbocker hit a sacrifice fly to center, Ross,C
scored (BBBCFX)
14-10 2 1-- 32 Tebbetts grounded out to short (BBCFB>X)
************** Top of the 7th inning, Arsenal batting
14-10 0 --- 10 Herman,Bi grounded a single between third and short (BX)
14-10 0 1-- 10 Gantenbein flied out to center (BX)
14-10 1 1-- 22 Warren flied out to right (BCBCFX)
14-10 2 1-- 32 Webb walked, Herman,Bi to second (FCBBB>F>B)
14-10 2 12- 01 Niggeling popped out to third (CX)
************** Bottom of the 7th inning, Monsters batting
14-10 0 --- 11 Hoag grounded out to third (BFX)
14-10 1 --- 20 Whitehead,B lined a single to right center (BBX)
14-10 1 1-- 21 Koy flied out to right (1BBFX)
14-10 2 1-- 00 Niggeling threw a wild pitch, Whitehead,B to second (B)
14-10 2 -2- 32 York struck out (B.BCSBC)
************** Top of the 8th inning, Arsenal batting
14-10 0 --- 12 Hack lined a single to right (CBFX)
14-10 0 1-- 21 Keller reached on an infield single to the pitcher, Hack
to second (BCBX)
14-10 0 12- 22 Selkirk grounded a single between first and second, Hack
scored, Keller to second (BFBFX)
15-10 0 12- 12 Greenberg grounded into a double play, Knickerbocker to
Mueller,H to York, Keller to third (SCBX)
15-10 2 --3 01 Herman,Bi grounded out to third (CX)
************** Bottom of the 8th inning, Monsters batting
15-10 0 --- 00 Ross,C lined a single to shallow center (X)
15-10 0 1-- 22 Frye struck out (BCSBS)
15-10 1 1-- 30 Mueller,H walked, Ross,C to second (BBBB)
Page now pitching
Solters now playing right field
15-10 1 12- 22 Knickerbocker struck out (CBFBS)
15-10 2 12- 30 Tebbetts walked, Ross,C to third, Mueller,H to second
(BBBB)
15-10 2 123 10 Hoag grounded to short, forcing Tebbetts at second (BX)
************** Top of the 9th inning, Arsenal batting
15-10 0 --- 22 Gantenbein lined a single down the right field line
(FBCBFX)
15-10 0 1-- 12 Warren grounded a single up the middle, Gantenbein to
second (CFBX)
15-10 0 12- 31 Webb walked, Gantenbein to third, Warren to second
(BbCBBB)
15-10 0 123 21 Solters grounded a single up the middle, Gantenbein
scored, Warren scored, Webb to second (CBBX)
17-10 0 12- 10 Hack doubled deep to left center, Webb scored, Solters
scored (BX)
19-10 0 -2- 32 Keller struck out (BBCFBS)
19-10 1 -2- 12 Page reached on an infield single to second, Hack to
third (BCSFX)
19-10 1 1-3 12 Greenberg hit a sacrifice fly to left, Hack scored (SFBFX)
20-10 2 1-- 12 Tebbetts allowed a passed ball, Page to second (CBFB)
20-10 2 -2- 22 Herman,Bi lined a single to left, Page to third (CBFB.X)
20-10 2 1-3 32 Gantenbein struck out (BCSBB>S)
************** Bottom of the 9th inning, Monsters batting
20-10 0 --- 02 Whitehead,B lined a single to right center (CFFX)
Gustine pinch hitting for Koy
20-10 0 1-- 02 Gustine flied out to center (CFX)
20-10 1 1-- 30 York walked, Whitehead,B to second (BBBB)
20-10 1 12- 10 Ross,C grounded out to third, Whitehead,B to third, York
to second (BX)
20-10 2 -23 02 Frye struck out (CCC)