| Name | Name | AVG |
| Danny Tartabull | Magpies | .361 |
| Julio Franco | Guardians | .353 |
| Edgar Martinez | Vaqueros | .339 |
| Rafael Palmeiro* | Lemurs | .335 |
| Steve Sax | Plainsmen | .331 |
| Wade Boggs* | Lemurs | .329 |
| Eddie Murray# | Rockets | .328 |
| Will Clark* | Millers | .326 |
| Tony Gwynn* | Mud Hens | .325 |
| B.J. Surhoff* | Mud Hens | .323 |
| Rickey Henderson | Plainsmen | .322 |
| Ozzie Smith# | Plainsmen | .320 |
| Harold Baines* | Zoo Crew | .318 |
| Roberto Alomar# | Gnomes | .316 |
| Paul Molitor | Plainsmen | .314 |
| Brett Butler* | Gnomes | .314 |
| Ken Griffey Jr.* | Phantoms | .312 |
| Luis Polonia* | Mud Hens | .312 |
| Felix Jose# | Aviators | .311 |
| Frank Thomas | Brushbacks | .309 |
| Juan Gonzalez | Gnomes | .309 |
| Bobby Bonilla# | SpaceMen | .305 |
| Cal Ripken | Zoo Crew | .305 |
| Darryl Strawberry* | Grays | .302 |
| Barry Larkin | Mud Hens | .301 |
| Ryne Sandberg | Rockets | .300 |
| Barry Bonds* | Phantoms | .300 |
| Marquis Grissom | Millers | .295 |
| Kirby Puckett | Plainsmen | .292 |
| Mark Grace* | Game Sox | .291 |
| Matt Williams | SpaceMen | .291 |
| Kal Daniels* | Magpies | .290 |
| Mel Hall* | Vaqueros | .290 |
| Lou Whitaker* | Grays | .288 |
| Travis Fryman | Gnomes | .287 |
| Wally Joyner* | Aviators | .287 |
| Jim Gantner* | Vaqueros | .286 |
| Mike Devereaux | Metropolitans | .285 |
| Ruben Sierra# | Pachyderms | .285 |
| Mike Greenwell* | Pachyderms | .285 |
| Robin Ventura* | Mud Hens | .284 |
| Ellis Burks | Canaries | .283 |
| Tim Raines# | Zoo Crew | .280 |
| John Olerud* | Vaqueros | .280 |
| Chris Sabo | Phantoms | .278 |
| Jody Reed | Game Sox | .278 |
| Dave Henderson | Rockets | .277 |
| Ivan Calderon | Aviators | .275 |
| Tony Phillips# | Grays | .274 |
| Ray Lankford* | Rough Riders | .273 |
| Lance Johnson* | Vaqueros | .270 |
| Leo Gomez | Millers | .270 |
| Ozzie Guillen* | Aviators | .269 |
| Gary Gaetti | Magpies | .267 |
| Jose Canseco | Plainsmen | .265 |
| Fred McGriff* | Phantoms | .265 |
| Don Mattingly* | Damage | .265 |
| Luis Gonzalez* | Kingsmen | .264 |
| Steve Buechele | Brushbacks | .264 |
| Greg Vaughn | Canaries | .262 |
| Tim Wallach | Rockets | .262 |
| Kent Hrbek* | Grays | .261 |
| Ron Gant | Aviators | .258 |
| Harold Reynolds# | Pachyderms | .257 |
| Mickey Tettleton# | Plainsmen | .256 |
| George Bell | SpaceMen | .256 |
| Chili Davis# | Brushbacks | .256 |
| Paul O'Neill* | Millers | .255 |
| Carlos Baerga# | Mud Hens | .255 |
| Andre Dawson | Rockets | .254 |
| Jose Lind | Magpies | .253 |
| Milt Cuyler# | Rough Riders | .253 |
| Howard Johnson# | Firebugs | .251 |
| Benito Santiago | Aviators | .251 |
| Dave Winfield | Kingsmen | .251 |
| Devon White# | Vaqueros | .250 |
| Ken Caminiti# | Game Sox | .247 |
| Delino DeShields* | Aviators | .244 |
| Mark McGwire | Canaries | .241 |
| Robin Yount | Grays | .241 |
| Robby Thompson | Firebugs | .235 |
| Charlie Hayes | Aviators | .235 |
| Pete O'Brien* | Magpies | .227 |
| Tom Brunansky | Game Sox | .217 |
| Kevin Maas* | Rough Riders | .215 |
| Omar Vizquel# | Yard Goats | .191 |