| Name | Name | AVG |
| Edgar Martinez | Vaqueros | .342 |
| Bip Roberts# | Magpies | .341 |
| Steve Finley* | Dwarves | .340 |
| Shane Mack | Plainsmen | .334 |
| John Kruk* | Gnomes | .332 |
| Ken Caminiti# | Pickles | .328 |
| Ozzie Smith# | Plainsmen | .325 |
| Frank Thomas | Brushbacks | .325 |
| George Brett* | Guardians | .321 |
| Carlos Baerga# | Mud Hens | .321 |
| Will Clark* | Millers | .319 |
| Roberto Alomar# | Gnomes | .316 |
| Mark Grace* | Pickles | .311 |
| Barry Larkin | Mud Hens | .311 |
| Ken Griffey* | Phantoms | .310 |
| Craig Biggio | Dwarves | .308 |
| Ruben Sierra# | Pachyderms | .307 |
| Larry Walker* | Firebugs | .307 |
| Chili Davis# | Brushbacks | .306 |
| Kirby Puckett | Plainsmen | .304 |
| Tony Phillips# | Grays | .303 |
| Andy Van Slyke* | Aviators | .303 |
| Rafael Palmeiro* | Dwarves | .301 |
| Tim Raines# | Rough Riders | .300 |
| Barry Bonds* | Phantoms | .297 |
| Ray Lankford* | Rough Riders | .297 |
| Pat Listach# | Aviators | .292 |
| Gary Sheffield | Zoo Crew | .291 |
| Terry Pendleton# | Gnomes | .290 |
| Robin Ventura* | Mud Hens | .289 |
| Wally Joyner* | Leathernecks | .286 |
| Roberto Kelly | Leathernecks | .286 |
| Lou Whitaker* | Grays | .284 |
| Mark Whiten# | Dwarves | .284 |
| Chad Curtis | Pachyderms | .284 |
| Darren Daulton* | Brushbacks | .284 |
| Brady Anderson* | Mud Hens | .283 |
| Jody Reed | Pickles | .283 |
| Delino DeShields* | Aviators | .283 |
| Tony Fernandez# | Dwarves | .283 |
| Kenny Lofton* | Millers | .282 |
| Dave Hollins# | Guardians | .280 |
| Jeff Bagwell | Gnomes | .279 |
| Charlie Hayes | Aviators | .277 |
| Mel Hall* | Vaqueros | .277 |
| Paul Molitor | Plainsmen | .276 |
| Mike Devereaux | Metropolitans | .276 |
| Juan Gonzalez | Gnomes | .276 |
| Don Mattingly* | Aviators | .276 |
| Omar Vizquel# | Yard Goats | .274 |
| Carney Lansford | Firebugs | .274 |
| Marquis Grissom | Phantoms | .273 |
| Gregg Jefferies# | Phantoms | .271 |
| Harold Baines* | Zoo Crew | .271 |
| Chuck Knoblauch | Phantoms | .270 |
| Brett Butler* | Gnomes | .269 |
| Ryne Sandberg | Plainsmen | .269 |
| Andre Dawson | Aviators | .267 |
| Fred McGriff* | Phantoms | .264 |
| Travis Fryman | Gnomes | .262 |
| Leo Gomez | Millers | .260 |
| Albert Belle | Brushbacks | .257 |
| Steve Buechele | Brushbacks | .255 |
| Otis Nixon# | Pickles | .254 |
| Dave Justice* | Millers | .253 |
| Dave Winfield | Kingsmen | .252 |
| Mickey Tettleton# | Plainsmen | .252 |
| Brian McRae# | Firebugs | .251 |
| Mariano Duncan | Zoo Crew | .250 |
| Cecil Fielder | Pachyderms | .248 |
| Dean Palmer | Metropolitans | .247 |
| Eddie Murray# | Rockets | .245 |
| Matt Williams | SpaceMen | .243 |
| Paul O'Neill* | Millers | .243 |
| Jay Buhner | Leathernecks | .242 |
| Mark McGwire | Canaries | .239 |
| Jay Bell | Pachyderms | .238 |
| Robby Thompson | Firebugs | .238 |
| Greg Vaughn | Canaries | .235 |
| Cal Ripken | Zoo Crew | .231 |
| Devon White# | Vaqueros | .229 |
| Bobby Bonilla# | SpaceMen | .227 |
| Robin Yount | Guardians | .227 |
| Wade Boggs* | Dwarves | .226 |
| Tim Wallach | Rockets | .220 |
| Kelly Gruber | Canaries | .213 |
| Joe Oliver | Guardians | .212 |