| Name | Name | HR |
| Roger Maris* | Jakes | 44 |
| Harmon Killebrew | Robbers | 41 |
| Mickey Mantle# | Jakes | 39 |
| Jim Gentile* | Mets | 35 |
| Rocky Colavito | Saints | 30 |
| Joe Adcock | Black Cats | 29 |
| Orlando Cepeda | Saints | 28 |
| Willie Mays | Bears | 27 |
| Norm Cash* | Lightning | 26 |
| Frank Robinson | Mets | 26 |
| Eddie Mathews* | Lakers | 24 |
| Gene Freese | Black Cats | 23 |
| Jim Landis | Jakes | 23 |
| Billy Williams* | Lightning | 23 |
| Bob Allison | Rockets | 22 |
| Gordy Coleman* | Frigates | 21 |
| Ken Boyer | Mets | 19 |
| Don Hoak | Jakes | 18 |
| Hank Aaron | Bears | 17 |
| Bubba Phillips | Bears | 17 |
| Charley Smith | Bears | 17 |
| Johnny Blanchard* | Jakes | 16 |
| Elston Howard | Frigates | 16 |
| Jim King* | Tarheels | 16 |
| Bill Skowron | Jakes | 16 |
| Duke Snider* | Bears | 16 |
| Ernie Banks | Argonauts | 15 |
| Earl Battey | Lightning | 15 |
| Bill Bruton* | Frigates | 15 |
| Roberto Clemente | Lightning | 15 |
| Gene Green | Lightning | 15 |
| Al Kaline | Tigers | 15 |
| Willie Kirkland* | Frigates | 15 |
| Vada Pinson* | Lightning | 15 |
| Dick Stuart | Robbers | 15 |
| Gary Geiger* | Frigates | 14 |
| Ted Kluszewski* | Bears | 14 |
| Bill White* | Tarheels | 14 |
| Felipe Alou | Ahabs | 13 |
| Yogi Berra* | Jakes | 13 |
| Woodie Held | Frigates | 13 |
| Norm Siebern* | Rockets | 13 |
| Leon Wagner* | Black Cats | 13 |
| Don Demeter | Ahabs | 13 |
| Lee Maye* | Tigers | 12 |
| Earl Averill | Mets | 11 |
| Johnny Callison* | Tarheels | 11 |
| Bill Mazeroski | Lightning | 11 |
| Roy McMillan | Mets | 11 |
| John Romano | Mets | 11 |
| Ron Santo | Tarheels | 11 |
| Bob Cerv | Black Cats | 11 |
| George Altman* | Robbers | 10 |
| Charlie Neal | Ahabs | 10 |
| Gus Triandos | Saints | 10 |
| Don Zimmer | Saints | 10 |
| Ken Hunt | Mets | 9 |
| John Roseboro* | Ahabs | 9 |
| Roy Sievers | Saints | 9 |
| Sammy Taylor* | Rockets | 9 |
| Lee Thomas* | Robbers | 9 |
| Matty Alou* | Ahabs | 8 |
| Clete Boyer | Lightning | 8 |
| Ron Fairly* | Mets | 8 |
| Frank Malzone | Frigates | 8 |
| Floyd Robinson* | Black Cats | 8 |
| Carl Sawatski* | Bears | 8 |
| Al Smith | Argonauts | 8 |
| Bill Virdon* | Black Cats | 8 |
| Chuck Essegian | Ahabs | 8 |
| Daryl Spencer | Rockets | 8 |
| Jerry Adair | Robbers | 7 |
| Steve Boros | Bears | 7 |
| Jim Davenport | Rockets | 7 |
| Willie Davis* | Mets | 7 |
| Jerry Lumpe* | Mets | 7 |
| Willie McCovey* | Robbers | 7 |
| Wally Moon* | Mets | 7 |
| Stan Musial* | Lakers | 7 |
| Earl Robinson | Bears | 7 |
| Billy Martin | Bears | 7 |
| Luis Aparicio | Lightning | 6 |
| Steve Bilko | Frigates | 6 |
| Frank Bolling | Frigates | 6 |
| Joe Cunningham* | Saints | 6 |
| Tommy Davis | Ahabs | 6 |
| Chuck Hinton | Ahabs | 6 |
| Frank Howard | Robbers | 6 |
| Jackie Jensen | Frigates | 6 |
| Minnie Minoso | Argonauts | 6 |
| Wally Post | Frigates | 6 |
| Bobby Richardson | Jakes | 6 |
| Willie Tasby | Lakers | 6 |
| Ed Bailey* | Black Cats | 6 |
| Bobby Del Greco | Tarheels | 6 |
| Deron Johnson | Robbers | 6 |
| Frank Thomas | Saints | 6 |
| Ruben Amaro | Ahabs | 5 |
| Jackie Brandt | Robbers | 5 |
| Smoky Burgess* | Argonauts | 5 |
| Pumpsie Green# | Tigers | 5 |
| Marty Keough* | Lakers | 5 |
| Jim Lemon | Argonauts | 5 |
| Sherm Lollar | Lakers | 5 |
| Jim Pagliaroni | Tarheels | 5 |
| Albie Pearson* | Tigers | 5 |
| Joe Pignatano | Saints | 5 |
| Gene Woodling* | Rockets | 5 |
| Marv Throneberry* | Jakes | 5 |
| Eddie Bressoud | Ahabs | 4 |
| Wayne Causey* | Argonauts | 4 |
| Jim Gilliam# | Saints | 4 |
| Tony Gonzalez* | Argonauts | 4 |
| Dick Groat | Black Cats | 4 |
| Julian Javier | Saints | 4 |
| Eddie Kasko | Jakes | 4 |
| Brooks Robinson | Ahabs | 4 |
| Andre Rodgers | Frigates | 4 |
| Johnny Temple | Black Cats | 4 |
| Lee Walls | Bears | 4 |
| Vic Wertz* | Argonauts | 4 |
| Dick Brown | Ahabs | 3 |
| Don Buddin | Jakes | 3 |
| Mike de la Hoz | Black Cats | 3 |
| Tito Francona* | Lakers | 3 |
| Billy Goodman* | Tigers | 3 |
| Ron Hansen | Tarheels | 3 |
| Pancho Herrera | Argonauts | 3 |
| Gil Hodges | Ahabs | 3 |
| Jerry Kindall | Tarheels | 3 |
| Tony Kubek* | Robbers | 3 |
| Dale Long* | Tarheels | 3 |
| Danny O'Connell | Tigers | 3 |
| Jim Piersall | Rockets | 3 |
| Vic Power | Tigers | 3 |
| Pete Runnels* | Ahabs | 3 |
| Ed Sadowski | Tigers | 3 |
| Haywood Sullivan | Bears | 3 |
| Joe Torre | Robbers | 3 |
| Zoilo Versalles | Lakers | 3 |
| Dick Williams | Rockets | 3 |
| Jake Wood | Lakers | 3 |
| Carl Yastrzemski* | Saints | 3 |
| Reno Bertoia | Bears | 3 |
| Jim Rivera* | Ahabs | 3 |
| Walt Bond* | Frigates | 2 |
| Cam Carreon | Lakers | 2 |
| Elio Chacon | Tigers | 2 |
| Pete Daley | Bears | 2 |
| Curt Flood | Tarheels | 2 |
| Hank Foiles | Jakes | 2 |
| Chuck Hiller* | Black Cats | 2 |
| Dick Howser | Lakers | 2 |
| Bob Johnson | Lightning | 2 |
| Jerry Lynch* | Jakes | 2 |
| Charlie Maxwell* | Black Cats | 2 |
| John Orsino | Frigates | 2 |
| Bobo Osborne* | Lightning | 2 |
| Hal Smith | Rockets | 2 |
| Chuck Cottier | Argonauts | 2 |
| Wes Covington* | Tigers | 2 |
| Joey Amalfitano | Tarheels | 1 |
| Gus Bell* | Black Cats | 1 |
| Harry Bright | Frigates | 1 |
| Doug Camilli | Frigates | 1 |
| Leo Cardenas | Rockets | 1 |
| Del Crandall | Black Cats | 1 |
| Clay Dalrymple* | Tarheels | 1 |
| Don Dillard* | Lightning | 1 |
| Johnny Edwards* | Black Cats | 1 |
| Chico Fernandez | Tigers | 1 |
| Alex Grammas | Bears | 1 |
| Lenny Green* | Lakers | 1 |
| Carroll Hardy | Robbers | 1 |
| Harvey Kuenn | Black Cats | 1 |
| Norm Larker* | Lakers | 1 |
| Gene Leek | Robbers | 1 |
| Don Leppert | Argonauts | 1 |
| Hector Lopez | Tigers | 1 |
| Dick McAuliffe* | Argonauts | 1 |
| Tim McCarver* | Mets | 1 |
| Don Mincher* | Lakers | 1 |
| Billy Moran | Robbers | 1 |
| Hal Naragon* | Saints | 1 |
| Jose Pagan | Lakers | 1 |
| Leo Posada | Tigers | 1 |
| Chuck Schilling | Argonauts | 1 |
| Dick Schofield# | Ahabs | 1 |
| Bob Skinner* | Mets | 1 |
| Hal Smith | Tigers | 1 |
| Russ Snyder* | Ahabs | 1 |
| Al Spangler* | Tigers | 1 |
| Don Taussig | Tigers | 1 |
| Moe Thacker | Black Cats | 1 |
| Coot Veal | Argonauts | 1 |
| Bob Nieman | Jakes | 1 |
| Carl Warwick | Lakers | 1 |
| Richie Ashburn* | Robbers | 0 |
| Bob Aspromonte | Ahabs | 0 |
| Dick Bertell | Argonauts | 0 |
| Ed Bouchee* | Rockets | 0 |
| Marv Breeding | Mets | 0 |
| Rocky Bridges | Jakes | 0 |
| Jim Busby | Frigates | 0 |
| Joe Christopher | Lightning | 0 |
| Lou Clinton | Ahabs | 0 |
| Dan Dobbek* | Argonauts | 0 |
| Nellie Fox* | Lakers | 0 |
| Bill Freehan | Argonauts | 0 |
| Jim Fregosi | Tarheels | 0 |
| Tom Haller* | Tigers | 0 |
| Ken Hamlin | Rockets | 0 |
| Tim Harkness* | Black Cats | 0 |
| Al Heist | Frigates | 0 |
| Whitey Herzog* | Tarheels | 0 |
| Charlie James | Saints | 0 |
| Lou Johnson | Lightning | 0 |
| Mack Jones* | Tarheels | 0 |
| Hobie Landrith* | Saints | 0 |
| Bobby Malkmus | Frigates | 0 |
| Felix Mantilla | Ahabs | 0 |
| J.C. Martin* | Mets | 0 |
| Bubba Morton | Frigates | 0 |
| Russ Nixon* | Robbers | 0 |
| Gene Oliver | Lakers | 0 |
| Dave Philley# | Bears | 0 |
| Del Rice | Jakes | 0 |
| Mike Roarke | Black Cats | 0 |
| Bob Rodgers# | Bears | 0 |
| Bob Roselli | Frigates | 0 |
| Tom Satriano* | Black Cats | 0 |
| Red Schoendienst# | Argonauts | 0 |
| Norm Sherry | Saints | 0 |
| Bobby Smith | Rockets | 0 |
| Tony Taylor | Rockets | 0 |
| Jose Valdivielso | Mets | 0 |
| Sammy White | Frigates | 0 |
| Bob Will* | Black Cats | 0 |
| Maury Wills# | Saints | 0 |
| Eddie Yost | Tigers | 0 |
| Jerry Zimmerman | Tigers | 0 |
| Bud Zipfel* | Black Cats | 0 |
| Ken Aspromonte | Rockets | 0 |
| Julio Becquer* | Ahabs | 0 |
| Don Blasingame* | Tigers | 0 |
| Gino Cimoli | Saints | 0 |
| Clint Courtney* | Argonauts | 0 |
| Darrell Johnson | Bears | 0 |
| Joe Koppe | Saints | 0 |
| Bob Lillis | Lakers | 0 |
| George Thomas | Lightning | 0 |
| Bill Tuttle | Rockets | 0 |