| Name | Name | HR |
| Willie Mays | Bears | 18 |
| Walt Bond* | Black Cats | 11 |
| Hank Aaron | Bears | 10 |
| Harmon Killebrew | Bombers | 10 |
| Jim Gentile* | Rockets | 10 |
| Curt Blefary* | Tigers | 9 |
| Tony Gonzalez* | Argonauts | 9 |
| James Hart | Mets | 9 |
| Mickey Mantle# | Jakes | 9 |
| Felipe Alou | Ahabs | 8 |
| Clete Boyer | Tigers | 8 |
| Ed Kirkpatrick* | Black Cats | 8 |
| Frank Robinson | Mets | 8 |
| Joe Torre | Bombers | 8 |
| Billy Williams* | Lightning | 8 |
| Ernie Banks | Lightning | 7 |
| Johnny Callison* | Tarheels | 7 |
| Eddie Mathews* | Colt .45's | 7 |
| Vada Pinson* | Lightning | 7 |
| John Romano | Jakes | 7 |
| Ron Santo | Tarheels | 7 |
| Dick Stuart | Tourists | 7 |
| Leon Wagner* | Mets | 7 |
| Dick Allen | Frigates | 6 |
| Norm Cash* | Argonauts | 6 |
| Roberto Clemente | Lightning | 6 |
| Tony Conigliaro | Frigates | 6 |
| Woodie Held | Bears | 6 |
| Mack Jones* | Tarheels | 6 |
| Willie McCovey* | Bombers | 6 |
| Adolfo Phillips | Black Cats | 6 |
| Brooks Robinson | Ahabs | 6 |
| Bill Skowron | Jakes | 6 |
| Willie Smith* | Grays | 6 |
| Lee Thomas* | Black Cats | 6 |
| Leo Cardenas | Lightning | 5 |
| Tommy Harper | Tigers | 5 |
| Don Lock | Bears | 5 |
| Roger Repoz* | Jakes | 5 |
| Jim Wynn | Colt .45's | 5 |
| Don Buford# | Tarheels | 4 |
| Danny Cater | Grays | 4 |
| Rocky Colavito | Tourists | 4 |
| Ron Fairly* | Mets | 4 |
| Ken Harrelson | Frigates | 4 |
| Deron Johnson | Bombers | 4 |
| Johnny Lewis* | Bears | 4 |
| Ken McMullen | Lightning | 4 |
| Joe Morgan* | Bullies | 4 |
| Boog Powell* | Bears | 4 |
| Floyd Robinson* | Argonauts | 4 |
| Norm Siebern* | Black Cats | 4 |
| Willie Stargell* | Bullies | 4 |
| Rusty Staub* | Lightning | 4 |
| Tom Tresh# | Rockets | 4 |
| Bill White* | Tarheels | 4 |
| Carl Yastrzemski* | Tourists | 4 |
| Ray Barker* | Argonauts | 4 |
| Jerry Adair | Bombers | 3 |
| Joe Adcock | Bears | 3 |
| Max Alvis | Rockets | 3 |
| Frank Bolling | Frigates | 3 |
| Eddie Bressoud | Ahabs | 3 |
| Jose Cardenal | Bullies | 3 |
| Johnny Edwards* | Black Cats | 3 |
| Willie Horton | Bombers | 3 |
| Elston Howard | Frigates | 3 |
| Frank Howard | Bombers | 3 |
| Jim King* | Frigates | 3 |
| Ed Kranepool* | Rockets | 3 |
| Bill Mazeroski | Bears | 3 |
| Jim Pagliaroni | Tarheels | 3 |
| Joe Pepitone* | Frigates | 3 |
| Tony Perez | Grays | 3 |
| Paul Schaal | Bullies | 3 |
| Fred Whitfield* | Mets | 3 |
| Gene Alley | Tigers | 2 |
| Bob Allison | Frigates | 2 |
| Luis Aparicio | Rockets | 2 |
| Bob Aspromonte | Grays | 2 |
| Bob Bailey | Bombers | 2 |
| Sam Bowens | Frigates | 2 |
| Dick Brown | Ahabs | 2 |
| Billy Bryan* | Tourists | 2 |
| Smoky Burgess* | Rockets | 2 |
| Bob Chance* | Tarheels | 2 |
| Doug Clemens* | Black Cats | 2 |
| Donn Clendenon | Colt .45's | 2 |
| Gordy Coleman* | Grays | 2 |
| Wes Covington* | Rockets | 2 |
| Curt Flood | Tarheels | 2 |
| Jim Fregosi | Tarheels | 2 |
| Jim Gosger* | Bullies | 2 |
| Jimmie Hall* | Tourists | 2 |
| Ron Hansen | Grays | 2 |
| Al Kaline | Tigers | 2 |
| Rene Lachemann | Bullies | 2 |
| Jim Lefebvre# | Tourists | 2 |
| Felix Mantilla | Ahabs | 2 |
| Dick McAuliffe* | Argonauts | 2 |
| Tim McCarver* | Mets | 2 |
| Tommy McCraw* | Tigers | 2 |
| Gene Oliver | Tarheels | 2 |
| Rico Petrocelli | Jakes | 2 |
| Rich Rollins | Argonauts | 2 |
| Pete Rose# | Grays | 2 |
| Bob Skinner* | Tigers | 2 |
| Zoilo Versalles | Mets | 2 |
| Bill Virdon* | Rockets | 2 |
| John Bateman | Tourists | 1 |
| Earl Battey | Lightning | 1 |
| Ken Berry | Bullies | 1 |
| Ed Brinkman | Black Cats | 1 |
| Gates Brown* | Frigates | 1 |
| Larry Brown | Colt .45's | 1 |
| Bert Campaneris | Argonauts | 1 |
| Rico Carty | Lightning | 1 |
| Wayne Causey* | Bears | 1 |
| Clay Dalrymple* | Tarheels | 1 |
| Don Demeter | Ahabs | 1 |
| Tito Francona* | Bullies | 1 |
| Bill Freehan | Argonauts | 1 |
| Phil Gagliano | Black Cats | 1 |
| Jim Gilliam# | Tourists | 1 |
| Dick Green | Bombers | 1 |
| Lenny Green* | Ahabs | 1 |
| Tom Haller* | Tigers | 1 |
| Ken Hamlin | Grays | 1 |
| Mike Hershberger | Black Cats | 1 |
| Chuck Hinton | Ahabs | 1 |
| Tony Horton | Ahabs | 1 |
| Lou Johnson | Rockets | 1 |
| Willie Kirkland* | Grays | 1 |
| Bobby Knoop | Colt .45's | 1 |
| Jim Landis | Jakes | 1 |
| Jerry Lynch* | Tarheels | 1 |
| Manny Mota | Rockets | 1 |
| Albie Pearson* | Tigers | 1 |
| Jim Piersall | Tourists | 1 |
| Chico Salmon | Frigates | 1 |
| Duke Sims* | Bears | 1 |
| Ron Swoboda | Tourists | 1 |
| Sandy Valdespino* | Frigates | 1 |
| Pete Ward* | Bears | 1 |
| Maury Wills# | Tourists | 1 |
| Bobby Wine | Tigers | 1 |
| Johnny Blanchard* | Jakes | 1 |
| Pedro Gonzalez | Lightning | 1 |
| Lee Maye* | Tigers | 1 |
| Bernie Allen* | Bears | 0 |
| Sandy Alomar | Lightning | 0 |
| Jesus Alou | Ahabs | 0 |
| Matty Alou* | Ahabs | 0 |
| George Altman* | Jakes | 0 |
| Brant Alyea | Argonauts | 0 |
| Joey Amalfitano | Mets | 0 |
| Ruben Amaro | Lightning | 0 |
| Joe Azcue | Grays | 0 |
| Glenn Beckert | Lightning | 0 |
| Paul Blair | Colt .45's | 0 |
| Don Blasingame* | Tigers | 0 |
| Jackie Brandt | Grays | 0 |
| Ron Brand | Lightning | 0 |
| John Briggs* | Colt .45's | 0 |
| Lou Brock* | Colt .45's | 0 |
| Mike Brumley* | Colt .45's | 0 |
| Jerry Buchek | Rockets | 0 |
| Doug Camilli | Black Cats | 0 |
| Chris Cannizzaro | Tourists | 0 |
| Ed Charles | Jakes | 0 |
| Joe Christopher | Argonauts | 0 |
| Horace Clarke# | Jakes | 0 |
| Pat Corrales | Tigers | 0 |
| Del Crandall | Argonauts | 0 |
| Joe Cunningham* | Bombers | 0 |
| Vic Davalillo* | Colt .45's | 0 |
| Jim Davenport | Bullies | 0 |
| Tommy Davis | Ahabs | 0 |
| Willie Davis* | Mets | 0 |
| Mike de la Hoz | Jakes | 0 |
| Jake Gibbs* | Jakes | 0 |
| Julio Gotay | Tourists | 0 |
| Dick Groat | Bears | 0 |
| Ken Henderson# | Bombers | 0 |
| Jim Hickman | Argonauts | 0 |
| Dick Howser | Frigates | 0 |
| Ron Hunt | Black Cats | 0 |
| Julian Javier | Tourists | 0 |
| Alex Johnson | Mets | 0 |
| Bob Johnson | Argonauts | 0 |
| Cleon Jones | Grays | 0 |
| Dalton Jones* | Argonauts | 0 |
| Eddie Kasko | Jakes | 0 |
| John Kennedy | Ahabs | 0 |
| George Kernek* | Bears | 0 |
| Don Kessinger# | Bullies | 0 |
| Jerry Kindall | Argonauts | 0 |
| Chris Krug | Tarheels | 0 |
| Tony Kubek* | Bombers | 0 |
| Don Landrum* | Bullies | 0 |
| Hal Lanier | Ahabs | 0 |
| Don LeJohn | Tourists | 0 |
| Bob Lillis | Colt .45's | 0 |
| Phil Linz | Jakes | 0 |
| Hector Lopez | Tarheels | 0 |
| Jerry Lumpe* | Mets | 0 |
| Frank Malzone | Frigates | 0 |
| Roger Maris* | Jakes | 0 |
| J.C. Martin* | Mets | 0 |
| Dal Maxvill | Grays | 0 |
| Roy McMillan | Bombers | 0 |
| Denis Menke | Tarheels | 0 |
| Don Mincher* | Bullies | 0 |
| Dick Nen* | Black Cats | 0 |
| Russ Nixon* | Bombers | 0 |
| Joe Nossek | Grays | 0 |
| Tony Oliva* | Colt .45's | 0 |
| John Orsino | Frigates | 0 |
| Wes Parker# | Colt .45's | 0 |
| Roberto Pena | Frigates | 0 |
| Cap Peterson | Black Cats | 0 |
| Vic Power | Tigers | 0 |
| Frank Quilici | Rockets | 0 |
| Merritt Ranew* | Bears | 0 |
| Tommie Reynolds# | Tarheels | 0 |
| Bobby Richardson | Jakes | 0 |
| Andre Rodgers | Bombers | 0 |
| Bob Rodgers# | Bears | 0 |
| Cookie Rojas | Colt .45's | 0 |
| John Roseboro* | Ahabs | 0 |
| Vic Roznovsky* | Grays | 0 |
| Tom Satriano* | Colt .45's | 0 |
| Art Shamsky* | Frigates | 0 |
| Mike Shannon | Rockets | 0 |
| Charley Smith | Black Cats | 0 |
| Russ Snyder* | Jakes | 0 |
| Bill Sorrell* | Argonauts | 0 |
| Mickey Stanley | Jakes | 0 |
| Jimmy Stewart# | Ahabs | 0 |
| John Sullivan* | Grays | 0 |
| Jose Tartabull* | Mets | 0 |
| Tony Taylor | Rockets | 0 |
| Bob Tillman | Rockets | 0 |
| Jeff Torborg | Lightning | 0 |
| Dick Tracewski | Frigates | 0 |
| Bob Uecker | Colt .45's | 0 |
| Fred Valentine# | Bears | 0 |
| Al Weis# | Colt .45's | 0 |
| Don Wert | Lightning | 0 |
| Jake Wood | Frigates | 0 |
| Woody Woodward | Black Cats | 0 |
| Ed Bailey* | Bullies | 0 |
| Lou Clinton | Bullies | 0 |
| Billy Cowan | Jakes | 0 |
| Len Gabrielson* | Tigers | 0 |
| Chuck Hiller* | Ahabs | 0 |
| Dick Schofield# | Bullies | 0 |
| Al Spangler* | Tigers | 0 |
| Frank Thomas | Tourists | 0 |