| Name | Name | R |
| Albert Pujols | Moondogs | 136 |
| Manny Ramirez | Moondogs | 135 |
| Joe Mauer* | Moondogs | 130 |
| Adrian Gonzalez* | Fiddlers | 126 |
| B.J. Upton | Rebels | 119 |
| Vladimir Guerrero | Highlanders | 115 |
| Raul Ibanez* | Rockets | 115 |
| Hanley Ramirez | Dynamo | 113 |
| Kevin Youkilis | Warriors | 113 |
| Ryan Howard* | Highlanders | 112 |
| Grady Sizemore* | Rockets | 112 |
| Mark Teixeira# | Rebels | 112 |
| Jimmy Rollins# | Storm Giants | 107 |
| Aubrey Huff* | Powerhouse | 106 |
| David Wright | Dynamo | 105 |
| Jose Reyes# | Blue Crabs | 104 |
| Ichiro Suzuki* | Marshalls | 104 |
| Dustin Pedroia | Marshalls | 103 |
| Adam Dunn* | Storm Giants | 103 |
| J.D. Drew* | Rebels | 100 |
| Torii Hunter | Highlanders | 100 |
| J.J. Hardy | Farmers | 99 |
| Xavier Nady | Warriors | 99 |
| Evan Longoria | Rebels | 98 |
| Nick Markakis* | Pumas | 96 |
| Carlos Beltran# | Oil Barons | 95 |
| Milton Bradley# | Dynamo | 94 |
| Matt Holliday | Rambler | 94 |
| Nate McLouth* | River Pilots | 94 |
| Carlos Pena* | Barking Seals | 94 |
| Aramis Ramirez | Sandlappers | 94 |
| Alex Rodriguez | Zeppelins | 94 |
| Ryan Braun | Barking Seals | 93 |
| Cristian Guzman# | Powerhouse | 93 |
| Russell Martin | Peppers | 93 |
| Alex Rios | Farmers | 93 |
| Chase Utley* | Farmers | 93 |
| Troy Glaus | Highlanders | 92 |
| Derek Jeter | Owls | 92 |
| Hunter Pence | Terriers | 92 |
| Jason Giambi* | Dynamo | 91 |
| Brian Roberts# | T-Bones | 91 |
| Shane Victorino# | River Pilots | 91 |
| Chris Young | Terriers | 91 |
| Miguel Cabrera | Warriors | 90 |
| Chipper Jones# | Storm Giants | 90 |
| Jose Lopez | Oil Barons | 90 |
| Alfonso Soriano | Storm Giants | 90 |
| Stephen Drew* | Terriers | 89 |
| Jhonny Peralta | River Pilots | 87 |
| Marco Scutaro | Powerhouse | 87 |
| Garrett Atkins | Blue Crabs | 85 |
| Prince Fielder* | Farmers | 85 |
| Brian Giles* | Peppers | 85 |
| Melvin Mora | Blue Crabs | 85 |
| Ryan Theriot | Zeppelins | 85 |
| Placido Polanco | Sandlappers | 84 |
| Ian Kinsler | Jukes | 83 |
| Casey Blake | T-Bones | 83 |
| Curtis Granderson* | | 82 |
| Lance Berkman# | | 81 |
| David DeJesus* | Marshalls | 81 |
| Jermaine Dye | Moondogs | 81 |
| Edwin Encarnacion | Rambler | 81 |
| Corey Hart | Fiddlers | 81 |
| Carlos Quentin | Farmers | 81 |
| Garret Anderson* | Rambler | 80 |
| Brian McCann* | Frogs | 80 |
| Jim Thome* | Rockets | 79 |
| Jayson Werth | Storm Giants | 79 |
| Delmon Young | Powerhouse | 79 |
| Carlos Gomez | Barking Seals | 78 |
| Akinori Iwamura* | Frogs | 78 |
| Edgar Renteria | Moondogs | 78 |
| Skip Schumaker* | Sandlappers | 78 |
| Mark DeRosa | Fiddlers | 77 |
| Kelly Johnson* | Terriers | 77 |
| Ryan Ludwick | Jukes | 77 |
| Magglio Ordonez | Frogs | 77 |
| Yunel Escobar | Fiddlers | 76 |
| Justin Morneau* | Zeppelins | 76 |
| Geovany Soto | Grays | 76 |
| Vernon Wells | Warriors | 76 |
| Felipe Lopez# | Rockets | 76 |
| Jorge Cantu | Jukes | 75 |
| Johnny Damon* | Owls | 75 |
| Chone Figgins# | River Pilots | 75 |
| Josh Hamilton* | Owls | 75 |
| Carlos Lee | Sandlappers | 75 |
| Lastings Milledge | Buskers | 75 |
| Aaron Rowand | Blue Crabs | 75 |
| Bobby Abreu* | Dynamo | 74 |
| Carlos Delgado* | Peppers | 74 |
| Andre Ethier* | River Pilots | 74 |
| Derrek Lee | Grays | 74 |
| Jason Bay | Rebels | 74 |
| Robinson Cano* | Buskers | 73 |
| Conor Jackson | River Pilots | 73 |
| David Ortiz* | Storm Giants | 73 |
| Jack Cust* | Pumas | 72 |
| Alex Gordon* | Frogs | 72 |
| Cody Ross | Fiddlers | 72 |
| Michael Young | Warriors | 72 |
| Mark Teahen* | T-Bones | 71 |
| Ryan Sweeney* | Warriors | 70 |
| Rickie Weeks | Storm Giants | 70 |
| Bobby Crosby | Oil Barons | 69 |
| Miguel Tejada | Buskers | 69 |
| Jason Bartlett | Rebels | 68 |
| Kelly Shoppach | Buskers | 68 |
| Joey Votto* | Jukes | 68 |
| Randy Winn# | Zeppelins | 68 |
| Carlos Guillen# | | 67 |
| Mike Jacobs* | Frogs | 67 |
| Gary Matthews# | Powerhouse | 66 |
| Mark Kotsay* | Buskers | 66 |
| Coco Crisp# | Grays | 65 |
| Marlon Byrd | Peppers | 64 |
| Chris Davis* | Marshalls | 64 |
| Jeff Francoeur | Storm Giants | 64 |
| Luke Scott* | Highlanders | 64 |
| Jacoby Ellsbury* | Owls | 63 |
| Jose Guillen | Zeppelins | 63 |
| Brad Hawpe* | Barking Seals | 63 |
| Jason Kubel* | Rambler | 63 |
| Matt Kemp | Owls | 62 |
| David Murphy* | Grays | 62 |
| Denard Span* | Marshalls | 62 |
| Mark Ellis | Barking Seals | 61 |
| Ben Francisco | T-Bones | 61 |
| Fred Lewis* | Jukes | 61 |
| Bengie Molina | River Pilots | 61 |
| Nick Swisher# | Rockets | 61 |
| Ronnie Belliard | Highlanders | 60 |
| Mike Cameron | Pumas | 60 |
| James Loney* | Owls | 60 |
| Nick Punto# | Barking Seals | 60 |
| Dan Uggla | River Pilots | 60 |
| Ryan Doumit# | Barking Seals | 59 |
| Orlando Hudson# | Warriors | 59 |
| Alexei Ramirez | Blue Crabs | 59 |
| Brandon Phillips | Zeppelins | 58 |
| Mark Reynolds | Pumas | 58 |
| Mike Aviles | Pumas | 57 |
| Blake DeWitt* | Owls | 57 |
| Willy Taveras | Peppers | 57 |
| Joe Crede | Marshalls | 56 |
| Jody Gerut* | | 56 |
| Adam LaRoche* | Oil Barons | 56 |
| Pat Burrell | Warriors | 55 |
| Orlando Cabrera | Marshalls | 55 |
| Ramon Hernandez | Farmers | 55 |
| Eric Hinske* | T-Bones | 55 |
| Joe Inglett* | Barking Seals | 55 |
| Ty Wigginton | Marshalls | 55 |
| Ryan Zimmerman | Rockets | 55 |
| Adam Jones | Buskers | 54 |
| Mike Lowell | Fiddlers | 54 |
| Aaron Miles# | Dynamo | 54 |
| Rick Ankiel* | Moondogs | 53 |
| Brendan Harris | Barking Seals | 52 |
| Willie Harris* | Fiddlers | 52 |
| Hideki Matsui* | Rebels | 52 |
| Freddy Sanchez | Pumas | 52 |
| Ryan Spilborghs | Farmers | 52 |
| Justin Upton | Grays | 52 |
| Asdrubal Cabrera# | | 51 |
| Melky Cabrera# | Tigers | 51 |
| Justin Ruggiano | Jukes | 51 |
| Troy Tulowitzki | Grays | 51 |
| Juan Uribe | Highlanders | 51 |
| Brandon Boggs# | Peppers | 50 |
| Elijah Dukes | Terriers | 50 |
| Juan Pierre* | Frogs | 50 |
| Jason Varitek# | Powerhouse | 50 |
| Jay Bruce* | Terriers | 49 |
| Shin-Soo Choo* | Frogs | 49 |
| Willy Aybar# | Buskers | 48 |
| Clint Barmes | Frogs | 48 |
| Gregor Blanco* | Tigers | 48 |
| Alexi Casilla# | Grays | 48 |
| Kevin Kouzmanoff | Grays | 48 |
| Adam Lind* | Fiddlers | 48 |
| Adrian Beltre | Tigers | 47 |
| Gerald Laird | Warriors | 46 |
| Chris Snyder | Zeppelins | 46 |
| Fernando Tatis | Pumas | 46 |
| Casey Kotchman* | Terriers | 46 |
| Emil Brown | T-Bones | 45 |
| Lyle Overbay* | River Pilots | 45 |
| Ivan Rodriguez | Rebels | 45 |
| Yuniesky Betancourt | Jukes | 44 |
| A.J. Pierzynski* | Rambler | 44 |
| Billy Butler | Pumas | 43 |
| Ryan Garko | Marshalls | 43 |
| Reed Johnson | Buskers | 43 |
| Howie Kendrick | Owls | 43 |
| Jeff Mathis | Terriers | 43 |
| Marcus Thames | | 43 |
| Ramon Vazquez* | T-Bones | 43 |
| David Eckstein | Highlanders | 43 |
| Dan Johnson* | Buskers | 43 |
| Carl Crawford* | | 42 |
| Mike Fontenot* | Rebels | 42 |
| Todd Helton* | Powerhouse | 42 |
| Jamey Carroll | Barking Seals | 41 |
| Ryan Church* | Rockets | 41 |
| Ray Durham# | Tigers | 41 |
| Travis Buck* | Powerhouse | 40 |
| Luis Castillo# | Blue Crabs | 40 |
| Kosuke Fukudome* | T-Bones | 40 |
| Jerry Hairston | Dynamo | 40 |
| Kevin Millar | Buskers | 40 |
| Scott Rolen | Peppers | 40 |
| Jose Bautista | River Pilots | 40 |
| Doug Mientkiewicz* | Powerhouse | 39 |
| Jorge Velandia | Rockets | 39 |
| Michael Bourn* | Rambler | 38 |
| John Buck | Marshalls | 38 |
| Frank Catalanotto* | Powerhouse | 38 |
| Chase Headley# | Oil Barons | 38 |
| Mike Napoli | Dynamo | 38 |
| Jeremy Reed* | Blue Crabs | 38 |
| Jason Michaels | Blue Crabs | 38 |
| Michael Barrett | Owls | 37 |
| Edgar Gonzalez | Owls | 37 |
| Jed Lowrie# | Marshalls | 37 |
| Jay Payton | Highlanders | 37 |
| Erick Aybar# | T-Bones | 36 |
| Jeff Kent | Tigers | 36 |
| Jeff Keppinger | T-Bones | 36 |
| Yadier Molina | Highlanders | 36 |
| Gabe Gross* | Moondogs | 36 |
| Russell Branyan* | Moondogs | 35 |
| Jeremy Hermida* | Pumas | 35 |
| Adam Kennedy* | Moondogs | 35 |
| Josh Willingham | Jukes | 35 |
| Ken Griffey* | Barking Seals | 35 |
| Jeff Baker | Blue Crabs | 34 |
| Damion Easley | River Pilots | 34 |
| Joey Gathright* | Dynamo | 34 |
| Bill Hall | Grays | 34 |
| Kazuo Matsui# | Rebels | 34 |
| Hank Blalock* | Fiddlers | 33 |
| Sean Kazmar | Moondogs | 33 |
| Dallas McPherson* | Terriers | 33 |
| Dioner Navarro# | Blue Crabs | 33 |
| Daric Barton* | Terriers | 32 |
| Rafael Furcal# | Frogs | 32 |
| Cesar Izturis# | Peppers | 32 |
| Gabe Kapler | Warriors | 32 |
| Paul Konerko | Sandlappers | 32 |
| Ben Zobrist# | Tigers | 32 |
| Angel Berroa | Highlanders | 31 |
| Jesus Flores | Rambler | 31 |
| Luis Gonzalez* | Powerhouse | 31 |
| Mark Grudzielanek | Fiddlers | 31 |
| Franklin Gutierrez | Pumas | 31 |
| Maicer Izturis# | Sandlappers | 31 |
| Matt Joyce* | Frogs | 31 |
| Jason Kendall | Dynamo | 31 |
| Mark Loretta | Peppers | 31 |
| Brian Schneider* | Pumas | 31 |
| Aaron Boone | Terriers | 30 |
| Greg Dobbs* | Blue Crabs | 30 |
| Michael Cuddyer | Oil Barons | 29 |
| Ross Gload* | Peppers | 29 |
| Scott Hairston | Grays | 29 |
| Aaron Hill | Rambler | 29 |
| Scott Podsednik* | Buskers | 29 |
| Rajai Davis | Jukes | 29 |
| Jim Edmonds* | | 29 |
| Alfredo Amezaga# | Tigers | 28 |
| John Baker* | Fiddlers | 28 |
| Austin Kearns | Oil Barons | 28 |
| Miguel Olivo | Sandlappers | 28 |
| Ian Stewart* | Moondogs | 28 |
| Omar Infante | Sandlappers | 27 |
| Gary Sheffield | Frogs | 27 |
| Brandon Moss* | Grays | 27 |
| Geoff Blum# | Farmers | 26 |
| Sean Casey* | T-Bones | 26 |
| Jeff Clement* | Oil Barons | 26 |
| Pedro Feliz | Oil Barons | 26 |
| Jarrod Saltalamacchia# | Marshalls | 26 |
| Ramon Santiago# | Terriers | 26 |
| Kurt Suzuki | T-Bones | 26 |
| Gregg Zaun# | Tigers | 26 |
| Rich Aurilia | Warriors | 25 |
| Conor Gillaspie* | Moondogs | 25 |
| Khalil Greene | Pumas | 25 |
| Donnie Murphy | Terriers | 25 |
| Jose Vidro# | Rambler | 25 |
| Eric Bruntlett | Rambler | 24 |
| Alex Cora* | Warriors | 24 |
| Shannon Stewart | Blue Crabs | 24 |
| Chad Tracy* | Farmers | 24 |
| Wladimir Balentien | Frogs | 23 |
| Chris Dickerson* | Dynamo | 23 |
| Rob Mackowiak* | Tigers | 23 |
| Miguel Montero* | Sandlappers | 23 |
| Luis Rodriguez# | Peppers | 23 |
| Matt Treanor | T-Bones | 23 |
| Jack Wilson | | 23 |
| Willie Bloomquist | Rebels | 22 |
| Jack Hannahan* | Peppers | 22 |
| Nick Hundley | Fiddlers | 22 |
| Chris Iannetta | Grays | 22 |
| Jose Molina | Barking Seals | 22 |
| Jorge Posada# | Storm Giants | 22 |
| Dewayne Wise* | River Pilots | 22 |
| Matt Stairs* | Tigers | 22 |
| Michael Aubrey* | Buskers | 21 |
| Josh Bard# | Owls | 21 |
| Emmanuel Burriss# | Rambler | 21 |
| Joe Dillon | Zeppelins | 21 |
| Scott Hatteberg* | Rambler | 21 |
| Curtis Thigpen | Zeppelins | 21 |
| Javier Valentin# | Highlanders | 21 |
| Dmitri Young# | Oil Barons | 21 |
| Brian Anderson | Marshalls | 20 |
| Wes Bankston | Owls | 20 |
| Brandon Inge | Frogs | 20 |
| Kenji Johjima | Oil Barons | 20 |
| Joe Mather | Dynamo | 20 |
| Augie Ojeda# | Peppers | 20 |
| Robb Quinlan | Barking Seals | 20 |
| Mike Redmond | Powerhouse | 20 |
| J.R. Towles | Jukes | 20 |
| David Ross | Rockets | 20 |
| Rod Barajas | River Pilots | 19 |
| Alberto Callaspo# | Owls | 19 |
| Ronny Cedeno | Jukes | 19 |
| Craig Counsell* | T-Bones | 19 |
| Nelson Cruz | Owls | 19 |
| David Newhan* | Dynamo | 19 |
| Martin Prado | Peppers | 19 |
| Eugenio Velez# | Rambler | 19 |
| Delwyn Young# | Pumas | 19 |
| Joaquin Arias | Highlanders | 18 |
| Rob Bowen# | Tigers | 18 |
| Nomar Garciaparra | Pumas | 18 |
| Brett Gardner* | Peppers | 18 |
| Chris Gomez | Rockets | 18 |
| Carlos Gonzalez* | Farmers | 18 |
| Bryan LaHair* | Peppers | 18 |
| Andy Marte | Jukes | 18 |
| Juan Rivera | Oil Barons | 18 |
| Emilio Bonifacio# | Rambler | 18 |
| Kevin Cash | Warriors | 17 |
| Adam Everett | Rockets | 17 |
| Geoff Jenkins* | Farmers | 17 |
| Nick Johnson* | Terriers | 17 |
| Victor Martinez# | Buskers | 17 |
| Luis Rivas | Tigers | 17 |
| Sean Rodriguez | Grays | 17 |
| Chris Burke | Rebels | 16 |
| Miguel Cairo | Rebels | 16 |
| Ramon Castro | Farmers | 16 |
| Endy Chavez* | Pumas | 16 |
| German Duran | Tigers | 16 |
| Jonny Gomes | Farmers | 16 |
| Felix Pie* | Zeppelins | 16 |
| Mike Rabelo# | Rockets | 16 |
| Pablo Sandoval# | Buskers | 16 |
| Tony Clark# | Storm Giants | 16 |
| Wilson Betemit# | Buskers | 15 |
| Luke Montz | Storm Giants | 15 |
| Nyjer Morgan* | Frogs | 15 |
| Dan Murphy* | Highlanders | 15 |
| Wily Mo Pena | Oil Barons | 15 |
| Shawn Riggans | Sandlappers | 15 |
| Mike Rivera | Warriors | 15 |
| Carlos Ruiz | Rebels | 15 |
| Alberto Gonzalez | Rambler | 15 |
| Eric Byrnes | Moondogs | 14 |
| Chris Coste | Moondogs | 14 |
| Callix Crabbe# | Rockets | 14 |
| Chris Duncan* | Moondogs | 14 |
| Esteban German | Powerhouse | 14 |
| Ryan Langerhans* | Barking Seals | 14 |
| Jason LaRue | T-Bones | 14 |
| Abraham Nunez# | Storm Giants | 14 |
| Fernando Perez# | Grays | 14 |
| Oscar Salazar | Storm Giants | 14 |
| Chris Shelton | Frogs | 14 |
| Andy LaRoche | Grays | 14 |
| Paul Lo Duca | Tigers | 14 |
| Josh Anderson* | Jukes | 13 |
| Ben Broussard* | Tigers | 13 |
| Travis Metcalf | Frogs | 13 |
| Tony Pena | Fiddlers | 13 |
| Ryan Raburn | Marshalls | 13 |
| Dane Sardinha | Storm Giants | 13 |
| Seth Smith* | Grays | 13 |
| Greg Norton# | Grays | 13 |
| Matt Antonelli | Rambler | 12 |
| Brad Ausmus | Pumas | 12 |
| Darin Erstad* | Blue Crabs | 12 |
| Micah Hoffpauir* | Dynamo | 12 |
| Paul McAnulty* | Zeppelins | 12 |
| Angel Pagan# | Grays | 12 |
| Ryan Shealy | Highlanders | 12 |
| Mike Sweeney | Jukes | 12 |
| Clete Thomas* | Barking Seals | 12 |
| Jose Castillo | Rockets | 12 |
| Raul Chavez | Blue Crabs | 11 |
| Alex Cintron# | Moondogs | 11 |
| Travis Hafner* | T-Bones | 11 |
| Ryan Hanigan | River Pilots | 11 |
| Paul Hoover | Rockets | 11 |
| John McDonald | Zeppelins | 11 |
| Chad Moeller | Oil Barons | 11 |
| Scott Moore* | Jukes | 11 |
| Wil Nieves | Peppers | 11 |
| Cliff Pennington# | Barking Seals | 11 |
| Dave Roberts* | Rambler | 11 |
| Yorvit Torrealba | Fiddlers | 11 |
| Gil Velazquez | Jukes | 11 |
| Wes Helms | Farmers | 10 |
| Lou Montanez | Jukes | 10 |
| Brendan Ryan | Farmers | 10 |
| Matt Tolbert# | Barking Seals | 10 |
| Brian Barton | Oil Barons | 9 |
| Brian Bocock | Oil Barons | 9 |
| John Bowker* | Dynamo | 9 |
| Eric Chavez* | Owls | 9 |
| Matt Diaz | | 9 |
| Luis Hernandez# | Fiddlers | 9 |
| Andruw Jones | Marshalls | 9 |
| Ronny Paulino | Terriers | 9 |
| Humberto Quintero | Jukes | 9 |
| Cody Ransom | Blue Crabs | 9 |
| Jason Repko | Moondogs | 9 |
| Alex Romero* | Peppers | 9 |
| Will Venable* | Warriors | 9 |
| Rico Washington* | Storm Giants | 9 |
| Gary Bennett | Blue Crabs | 8 |
| Aaron Cunningham | Owls | 8 |
| Brandon Fahey* | Jukes | 8 |
| Sal Fasano | Rockets | 8 |
| Anderson Hernandez# | Warriors | 8 |
| Julio Lugo | Rebels | 8 |
| Corey Patterson* | Fiddlers | 8 |
| Nate Schierholtz* | Dynamo | 8 |
| So Taguchi | Buskers | 8 |
| Brandon Wood | Marshalls | 8 |
| Pablo Ozuna | Terriers | 8 |
| Jeff Bailey | Frogs | 7 |
| Josh Barfield | Frogs | 7 |
| Brian Buscher* | Dynamo | 7 |
| Raul Casanova# | Highlanders | 7 |
| Kory Casto* | Farmers | 7 |
| Jose Cruz# | Rockets | 7 |
| Nick Evans | Terriers | 7 |
| Ryan Freel | Blue Crabs | 7 |
| Ruben Gotay# | Rambler | 7 |
| Koyie Hill# | Tigers | 7 |
| Travis Ishikawa* | Terriers | 7 |
| Ryan Roberts | Rambler | 7 |
| Dusty Ryan | Frogs | 7 |
| Jeff Salazar* | Tigers | 7 |
| Omar Vizquel# | Powerhouse | 7 |
| Reggie Willits# | Barking Seals | 7 |
| Andy Phillips | Frogs | 7 |
| Moises Alou | Rockets | 6 |
| Rocco Baldelli | Oil Barons | 6 |
| Jamie Burke | Rockets | 6 |
| Toby Hall | Jukes | 6 |
| Steve Holm | Storm Giants | 6 |
| Chin-Lung Hu | Farmers | 6 |
| Jeff Larish* | Rambler | 6 |
| Drew Macias* | Frogs | 6 |
| Cameron Maybin | Dynamo | 6 |
| Scott McClain | Powerhouse | 6 |
| Steve Pearce | Pumas | 6 |
| Argenis Reyes# | Rambler | 6 |
| Eric Patterson* | Grays | 6 |
| Reggie Abercrombie | Blue Crabs | 5 |
| Henry Blanco | Fiddlers | 5 |
| Luis Cruz | Rambler | 5 |
| Brent Lillibridge | Marshalls | 5 |
| Mitch Maier* | Owls | 5 |
| Pete Orr* | Peppers | 5 |
| Max Ramirez | Marshalls | 5 |
| Jacque Jones* | Zeppelins | 5 |
| Danny Ardoin | Farmers | 4 |
| Roger Bernadina* | T-Bones | 4 |
| Reid Brignac* | Oil Barons | 4 |
| Robinson Cancel | Warriors | 4 |
| Travis Denker | Peppers | 4 |
| Morgan Ensberg | Tigers | 4 |
| Andy Gonzalez | | 4 |
| Jonathan Herrera# | Oil Barons | 4 |
| Brandon Jones* | Rebels | 4 |
| Joe Koshansky* | Marshalls | 4 |
| Corky Miller | Owls | 4 |
| Laynce Nix* | Powerhouse | 4 |
| Nick Stavinoha | T-Bones | 4 |
| Daryle Ward* | Rockets | 4 |
| Bobby Wilson | Blue Crabs | 4 |
| Juan Castro | Zeppelins | 4 |
| Adam Melhuse# | Barking Seals | 4 |
| Brad Wilkerson* | Terriers | 4 |
| Jeff Baisley | Buskers | 3 |
| Jason Botts# | Peppers | 3 |
| Jolbert Cabrera | Sandlappers | 3 |
| Chris Denorfia | Rockets | 3 |
| Michael Hollimon# | Owls | 3 |
| Norris Hopper | Frogs | 3 |
| Kevin Mench | Warriors | 3 |
| Guillermo Quiroz | Pumas | 3 |
| Danny Richar* | Frogs | 3 |
| Cory Sullivan* | Blue Crabs | 3 |
| Matt Tuiasosopo | Fiddlers | 3 |
| Luis Valbuena* | Grays | 3 |
| Tadahito Iguchi | Moondogs | 3 |
| Chip Ambres | Buskers | 2 |
| Wilkin Castillo# | Owls | 2 |
| Justin Christian | Moondogs | 2 |
| Buck Coats* | Peppers | 2 |
| Shelley Duncan | Barking Seals | 2 |
| Dexter Fowler# | Oil Barons | 2 |
| Tony Gwynn* | Powerhouse | 2 |
| Mike Hessman | Frogs | 2 |
| Brian Horwitz | Sandlappers | 2 |
| Kila Ka'aihue* | Powerhouse | 2 |
| Matt Macri | Rebels | 2 |
| Brian Myrow* | Rockets | 2 |
| Trot Nixon* | Buskers | 2 |
| Jerry Owens* | T-Bones | 2 |
| Brayan Pena# | Terriers | 2 |
| Omar Quintanilla* | Zeppelins | 2 |
| Adam Rosales | Grays | 2 |
| Randy Ruiz | Barking Seals | 2 |
| Travis Snider* | Oil Barons | 2 |
| Eider Torres# | Frogs | 2 |
| Jonathan Van Every* | Buskers | 2 |
| Mike Lamb* | Grays | 2 |
| Richie Sexson | Fiddlers | 2 |
| Frank Thomas | Dynamo | 2 |
| Robert Andino | Farmers | 1 |
| Brian Bixler | Pumas | 1 |
| Matt Brown | Buskers | 1 |
| Brett Carroll | Rebels | 1 |
| Brent Clevlen | Buskers | 1 |
| Mike DiFelice | Frogs | 1 |
| A.J. Ellis | Buskers | 1 |
| Cliff Floyd* | Fiddlers | 1 |
| Mat Gamel* | Oil Barons | 1 |
| Robby Hammock | Marshalls | 1 |
| Hernan Iribarren* | Fiddlers | 1 |
| Paul Janish | Dynamo | 1 |
| Rob Johnson | Sandlappers | 1 |
| Ramon Martinez | Warriors | 1 |
| Luis Maza | Oil Barons | 1 |
| Juan Miranda* | Moondogs | 1 |
| Craig Monroe | Warriors | 1 |
| Brad Nelson* | Sandlappers | 1 |
| Jayson Nix | Blue Crabs | 1 |
| Dan Ortmeier | Frogs | 1 |
| Ryan Rohlinger | Buskers | 1 |
| Freddy Sandoval# | Rebels | 1 |
| Craig Stansberry | Peppers | 1 |
| Joe Thurston* | Peppers | 1 |
| Jason Tyner* | Highlanders | 1 |
| Eliezer Alfonzo | Dynamo | 0 |
| Paul Bako* | Warriors | 0 |
| Brian Barden | Peppers | 0 |
| Edwin Bellorin | Rockets | 0 |
| Freddie Bynum* | River Pilots | 0 |
| Andy Cannizaro | Frogs | 0 |
| Luke Carlin# | Farmers | 0 |
| Francisco Cervelli | Owls | 0 |
| David Dellucci* | Warriors | 0 |
| Alcides Escobar | Terriers | 0 |
| Johnny Estrada# | Farmers | 0 |
| Josh Fields | Owls | 0 |
| Chris Getz* | Rambler | 0 |
| Greg Golson | Fiddlers | 0 |
| Brad Harman | Rebels | 0 |
| Michel Hernandez | Grays | 0 |
| Justin Huber | Warriors | 0 |
| Tug Hulett* | Sandlappers | 0 |
| John Jaso* | Grays | 0 |
| Elliot Johnson# | Rebels | 0 |
| George Kottaras* | Peppers | 0 |
| Hector Luna | Rambler | 0 |
| Lou Marson | Rambler | 0 |
| Edwin Maysonet | Rebels | 0 |
| Casey McGehee | Sandlappers | 0 |
| Jai Miller | Owls | 0 |
| Gustavo Molina | Fiddlers | 0 |
| Kendry Morales# | Marshalls | 0 |
| Mike Morse | Sandlappers | 0 |
| Ivan Ochoa | Zeppelins | 0 |
| Jason Perry* | Blue Crabs | 0 |
| Gregorio Petit | Warriors | 0 |
| Jason Pridie* | Blue Crabs | 0 |
| Vinny Rottino | Peppers | 0 |
| Mark Saccomanno | Storm Giants | 0 |
| Angel Salome | Moondogs | 0 |
| Gaby Sanchez | Owls | 0 |
| Omir Santos | Moondogs | 0 |
| Chris Stewart | Sandlappers | 0 |
| Josh Whitesell* | Owls | 0 |
| Matt Murton | Barking Seals | 0 |