| Primary |
| Name | Name | HR |
| Lou Gehrig* | Frogs | 53 |
| Jimmie Foxx | Blue Sox | 45 |
| Ripper Collins# | Mutuals | 35 |
| Hal Trosky* | Knights | 34 |
| Bob Johnson | Gassers | 32 |
| Wally Berger | Kingfish | 31 |
| Hank Greenberg | Gassers | 31 |
| Mel Ott* | Colonels | 27 |
| Earl Averill* | Knights | 26 |
| Babe Ruth* | Frogs | 25 |
| Tony Cuccinello | Frogs | 24 |
| Gabby Hartnett | Mutuals | 23 |
| Chick Hafey | Sprudels | 23 |
| Len Koenecke* | Gassers | 22 |
| Zeke Bonura | Red Sox | 22 |
| Joe Medwick | Colonels | 20 |
| Bill DeLancey* | Knights | 20 |
| Chuck Klein* | Seals | 15 |
| Marv Owen | Frogs | 15 |
| Goose Goslin* | Whiffenpoofs | 15 |
| Eric McNair | Frogs | 15 |
| Bruce Campbell* | Frogs | 15 |
| Heinie Manush* | Sprudels | 15 |
| Lefty O'Doul* | Blue Sox | 14 |
| Pinky Whitney | Knights | 14 |
| Al Simmons | Empires | 14 |
| Sam Leslie* | Seals | 13 |
| Jo-Jo Moore* | Glaziers | 12 |
| Paul Waner* | Seals | 12 |
| Jim Bottomley* | Colonels | 12 |
| George Puccinelli | Frogs | 12 |
| Fred Schulte | Frogs | 12 |
| Spud Davis | Colonels | 11 |
| Gus Suhr* | Glaziers | 11 |
| Arky Vaughan* | Titans | 11 |
| Odell Hale | Mutuals | 11 |
| Joe Cronin | Whiffenpoofs | 11 |
| Dolph Camilli* | Whiffenpoofs | 11 |
| Bucky Walters | Glaziers | 11 |
| Billy Urbanski | Mutuals | 10 |
| Buzz Boyle* | Titans | 10 |
| Bill Dickey* | Blue Sox | 10 |
| Pinky Higgins | Titans | 10 |
| Wes Schulmerich | Empires | 10 |
| Bill Terry* | Titans | 9 |
| Babe Herman* | Mutuals | 9 |
| George Watkins* | Gassers | 8 |
| Billy Jurges | Colonels | 8 |
| Marty McManus | Glaziers | 8 |
| Danny Taylor | Titans | 8 |
| Charlie Gehringer* | Kingfish | 8 |
| Johnny Burnett* | Frogs | 8 |
| Carl Reynolds | Empires | 8 |
| Roy Johnson* | Kingfish | 8 |
| Doc Cramer* | Knights | 8 |
| Jack Burns* | Kingfish | 8 |
| Harlond Clift | Blue Sox | 8 |
| Buddy Myer* | Gassers | 8 |
| Johnny Stone* | Knights | 8 |
| Johnny Moore* | Whiffenpoofs | 8 |
| Jack Rothrock# | Glaziers | 7 |
| Kiki Cuyler | Blue Sox | 7 |
| Randy Moore* | Gassers | 7 |
| Gordon Slade | Sprudels | 7 |
| Frankie Crosetti | Gassers | 7 |
| Ed Morgan | Empires | 7 |
| Joe Kuhel* | Titans | 7 |
| Travis Jackson | Gassers | 6 |
| Lonny Frey# | Mutuals | 6 |
| Ernie Lombardi | Titans | 6 |
| Tony Lazzeri | Titans | 6 |
| Joe Vosmik | Gassers | 6 |
| Sam West* | Blue Sox | 6 |
| Frankie Frisch# | Whiffenpoofs | 5 |
| Al Todd | Red Sox | 5 |
| Mickey Cochrane* | Empires | 5 |
| Ed Coleman* | Titans | 5 |
| Kiddo Davis | Blue Sox | 5 |
| Pepper Martin | Colonels | 4 |
| Johnny Vergez | Kingfish | 4 |
| Gus Mancuso | Glaziers | 4 |
| Augie Galan# | Mutuals | 4 |
| Freddy Lindstrom | Mutuals | 4 |
| Earl Grace* | Seals | 4 |
| Buck Jordan* | Whiffenpoofs | 4 |
| Hal Lee | Titans | 4 |
| Al Lopez | Kingfish | 4 |
| Ethan Allen | Red Sox | 4 |
| Pete Fox | Frogs | 4 |
| Jack Saltzgaver* | Red Sox | 4 |
| Moose Solters | Empires | 4 |
| Max Bishop* | Blue Sox | 4 |
| Cecil Travis* | Knights | 4 |
| Jimmy Dykes | Sprudels | 4 |
| Don Hurst* | Sprudels | 4 |
| Lyn Lary | Seals | 4 |
| Ed Madjeski | Red Sox | 4 |
| Cookie Lavagetto | Titans | 3 |
| Tommy Thevenow | Sprudels | 3 |
| Tom Padden | Glaziers | 3 |
| Shanty Hogan | Sprudels | 3 |
| Glenn Chapman | Gassers | 3 |
| Dick Bartell | Kingfish | 3 |
| Adam Comorosky | Blue Sox | 3 |
| Harlin Pool* | Seals | 3 |
| Sparky Adams | Gassers | 3 |
| Billy Rogell# | Knights | 3 |
| Frank Doljack | Empires | 3 |
| Ben Chapman | Colonels | 3 |
| Earle Combs* | Seals | 3 |
| Bill Knickerbocker | Empires | 3 |
| Ossie Bluege | Empires | 3 |
| Luke Sewell | Red Sox | 3 |
| Hughie Critz | Colonels | 2 |
| Charlie Grimm* | Empires | 2 |
| Billy Herman | Glaziers | 2 |
| Stan Hack* | Glaziers | 2 |
| Tuck Stainback | Sprudels | 2 |
| Babe Phelps | Gassers | 2 |
| Lloyd Waner* | Kingfish | 2 |
| Johnny Frederick* | Whiffenpoofs | 2 |
| Ray Berres | Kingfish | 2 |
| Johnny McCarthy* | Kingfish | 2 |
| Tony Piet | Whiffenpoofs | 2 |
| Jo-Jo White* | Whiffenpoofs | 2 |
| Gee Walker | Knights | 2 |
| Myril Hoag | Whiffenpoofs | 2 |
| Sam Rice* | Mutuals | 2 |
| Billy Werber | Knights | 2 |
| Rick Ferrell | Whiffenpoofs | 2 |
| Skinny Graham* | Red Sox | 2 |
| Ray Pepper | Sprudels | 2 |
| Dave Harris | Red Sox | 2 |
| Johnny Gill* | Frogs | 2 |
| Mark Mauldin | Red Sox | 2 |
| Frank Reiber | Frogs | 2 |
| Leo Durocher | Red Sox | 1 |
| Ernie Orsatti* | Seals | 1 |
| Burgess Whitehead | Red Sox | 1 |
| Phil Weintraub* | Glaziers | 1 |
| George Grantham* | Sprudels | 1 |
| Woody English | Blue Sox | 1 |
| Riggs Stephenson | Red Sox | 1 |
| Woody Jensen* | Glaziers | 1 |
| Wally Roettger | Sprudels | 1 |
| Tommy Thompson* | Mutuals | 1 |
| Al Spohrer | Sprudels | 1 |
| Les Mallon | Empires | 1 |
| Joe Mowry# | Kingfish | 1 |
| Joe Stripp | Seals | 1 |
| Jimmy Jordan | Blue Sox | 1 |
| Jim Bucher* | Gassers | 1 |
| Clyde Sukeforth* | Seals | 1 |
| Jimmie Wilson | Gassers | 1 |
| Mickey Haslin | Frogs | 1 |
| Irv Jeffries | Colonels | 1 |
| Bud Clancy* | Red Sox | 1 |
| Mark Koenig | Colonels | 1 |
| Jimmy Shevlin* | Kingfish | 1 |
| Ray Hayworth | Blue Sox | 1 |
| Rudy York | Kingfish | 1 |
| Red Rolfe* | Empires | 1 |
| George Selkirk* | Knights | 1 |
| Glenn Myatt* | Seals | 1 |
| Bill Cissell | Blue Sox | 1 |
| Dusty Cooke* | Titans | 1 |
| Gordie Hinkle | Empires | 1 |
| Lou Finney* | Blue Sox | 1 |
| Alan Strange | Glaziers | 1 |
| Rollie Hemsley | Frogs | 1 |
| Eddie Phillips | Gassers | 1 |
| Luke Appling | Glaziers | 1 |
| Evar Swanson | Glaziers | 1 |
| Mule Haas* | Red Sox | 1 |
| Chick Fullis | Red Sox | 1 |
| Bob O'Farrell | Frogs | 1 |
| Hack Wilson | Gassers | 1 |
| Bob Seeds | Glaziers | 1 |
| Red Kress | Glaziers | 1 |
| Bob Boken | Red Sox | 1 |
| Pat Crawford* | Titans | 0 |
| Buster Mills | Colonels | 0 |
| Francis Healy | Frogs | 0 |
| Gene Moore* | Empires | 0 |
| Blondy Ryan | Seals | 0 |
| Hank Leiber | Titans | 0 |
| Harry Danning | Colonels | 0 |
| Paul Richards | Kingfish | 0 |
| Homer Peel | Kingfish | 0 |
| Bennie Tate | Mutuals | 0 |
| Phil Cavarretta* | Sprudels | 0 |
| Pie Traynor | Kingfish | 0 |
| Pep Young | Kingfish | 0 |
| Pat Veltman | Whiffenpoofs | 0 |
| Bill Brubaker | Whiffenpoofs | 0 |
| Dick Gyselman | Gassers | 0 |
| Elbie Fletcher* | Blue Sox | 0 |
| Dan McGee | Whiffenpoofs | 0 |
| Johnnie Tyler# | Whiffenpoofs | 0 |
| Nick Tremark* | Red Sox | 0 |
| Wally Millies | Knights | 0 |
| Lou Chiozza* | Colonels | 0 |
| Harvey Hendrick* | Sprudels | 0 |
| Andy High* | Mutuals | 0 |
| Art Ruble* | Whiffenpoofs | 0 |
| Joe Holden* | Kingfish | 0 |
| Ed Boland* | Titans | 0 |
| Clyde Manion | Whiffenpoofs | 0 |
| Alex Kampouris | Knights | 0 |
| Ivey Shiver | Sprudels | 0 |
| Jake Flowers | Kingfish | 0 |
| Frank McCormick | Frogs | 0 |
| Flea Clifton | Kingfish | 0 |
| Heinie Schuble | Colonels | 0 |
| Sammy Byrd | Sprudels | 0 |
| Don Heffner | Whiffenpoofs | 0 |
| Art Jorgens | Sprudels | 0 |
| Dixie Walker* | Titans | 0 |
| Zack Taylor | Kingfish | 0 |
| Willie Kamm | Empires | 0 |
| Frankie Pytlak | Knights | 0 |
| Dutch Holland | Titans | 0 |
| Milt Galatzer* | Mutuals | 0 |
| Eddie Moore | Whiffenpoofs | 0 |
| Bill Brenzel | Titans | 0 |
| Kit Carson* | Gassers | 0 |
| Bob Garbark | Sprudels | 0 |
| Roy Spencer | Titans | 0 |
| Mel Almada* | Whiffenpoofs | 0 |
| Lou Legett | Empires | 0 |
| Joe Judge* | Sprudels | 0 |
| Al Niemiec | Seals | 0 |
| Red Kellett | Kingfish | 0 |
| Rabbit Warstler | Sprudels | 0 |
| Charlie Berry | Mutuals | 0 |
| Frankie Hayes | Knights | 0 |
| Bing Miller | Empires | 0 |
| Dib Williams | Seals | 0 |
| Charlie Moss | Mutuals | 0 |
| Jerry McQuaig | Empires | 0 |
| Oscar Melillo | Empires | 0 |
| Ollie Bejma | Titans | 0 |
| Debs Garms* | Glaziers | 0 |
| Frank Grube | Seals | 0 |
| Rogers Hornsby | Knights | 0 |
| Earl Clark | Whiffenpoofs | 0 |
| Grover Hartley | Frogs | 0 |
| Pete Susko* | Knights | 0 |
| Cliff Bolton* | Seals | 0 |
| John Kerr | Seals | 0 |
| Gus Dugas* | Empires | 0 |
| Elmer Klumpp | Blue Sox | 0 |
| Jake Powell | Empires | 0 |
| Fred Sington | Colonels | 0 |
| Jackie Hayes | Red Sox | 0 |
| Jocko Conlan* | Kingfish | 0 |
| Merv Shea | Whiffenpoofs | 0 |
| Frenchy Uhalt* | Mutuals | 0 |
| Joe Chamberlain | Kingfish | 0 |
| Muddy Ruel | Colonels | 0 |
| Frenchy Bordagaray | Seals | 0 |
| Milt Bocek | Glaziers | 0 |
| Charlie Uhlir* | Kingfish | 0 |
| Rip Radcliff* | Red Sox | 0 |
| George Caithamer | Gassers | 0 |
| Johnny Pasek | Knights | 0 |
| Harry McCurdy* | Seals | 0 |
| Freddie Muller | Blue Sox | 0 |
| Lew Riggs* | Glaziers | 0 |
| Bill Marshall | Kingfish | 0 |
| Hal Finney | Sprudels | 0 |
| Red Worthington | Seals | 0 |
| Marty Hopkins | Whiffenpoofs | 0 |
| Moe Berg | Colonels | 0 |
| Dick Porter* | Mutuals | 0 |