| Name | Name | AVG |
| Ted Williams* | Walleye | .368 |
| Nellie Fox* | Larks | .354 |
| Mickey Mantle# | Arsenal | .331 |
| Red Schoendienst# | Hawks | .320 |
| Stan Musial* | Aces | .315 |
| Gene Freese | Arsenal | .314 |
| Dick Groat | Muck Dogs | .313 |
| Vic Wertz* | Blues | .313 |
| Carl Furillo | Muck Dogs | .308 |
| Willie Mays | Muck Dogs | .306 |
| Tony Kubek* | Carp | .305 |
| Al Dark | Tigers | .305 |
| Richie Ashburn* | Royal Giants | .301 |
| Hank Aaron | Walleye | .294 |
| Wally Moon* | Stampers | .289 |
| Eddie Mathews* | Walleye | .287 |
| Walt Moryn* | Clowns | .284 |
| Gus Bell* | Grays | .283 |
| Don Blasingame* | Blues | .282 |
| Gus Zernial | Hawks | .281 |
| Larry Doby* | Aces | .279 |
| Ernie Banks | Royal Giants | .278 |
| Al Kaline | Royal Giants | .278 |
| Roy Sievers | Larks | .278 |
| Johnny Logan | Clowns | .277 |
| Gino Cimoli | Hawks | .275 |
| Gil McDougald | Muck Dogs | .275 |
| Bob Boyd* | Clowns | .274 |
| Eddie Yost | Grays | .273 |
| Frank Bolling | Arsenal | .272 |
| Don Hoak | Stampers | .271 |
| Yogi Berra* | Walleye | .270 |
| Minnie Minoso | Aces | .269 |
| Frank Thomas | Clowns | .267 |
| Frank Malzone | Tigers | .267 |
| Eddie Kasko | Hawks | .266 |
| Bill Mazeroski | Grays | .266 |
| Stan Lopata | Arsenal | .266 |
| Harvey Kuenn | Larks | .266 |
| Al Pilarcik* | Arsenal | .264 |
| Ed Bouchee* | Royal Giants | .264 |
| Frank Robinson | Stampers | .264 |
| Billy Martin | Thunderbolts | .263 |
| Jim Lemon | Aces | .258 |
| Bill Skowron | Tigers | .256 |
| Charlie Neal | Stampers | .254 |
| Elston Howard | Hawks | .254 |
| Jackie Jensen | Carp | .253 |
| Gus Triandos | Thunderbolts | .252 |
| Roberto Clemente | Larks | .247 |
| Roger Maris* | Stampers | .247 |
| Johnny Temple | Clowns | .242 |
| Billy Gardner | Larks | .239 |
| Ken Boyer | Blues | .237 |
| Ray Boone | Thunderbolts | .237 |
| Daryl Spencer | Muck Dogs | .236 |
| Willie Jones | Hawks | .235 |
| Luis Aparicio | Larks | .234 |
| Al Smith | Grays | .232 |
| Del Ennis | Aces | .231 |
| Tito Francona* | Stampers | .230 |
| Granny Hamner | Royal Giants | .229 |
| Charlie Maxwell* | Muck Dogs | .229 |
| Duke Snider* | Hawks | .227 |
| Sherm Lollar | Stampers | .224 |
| Jim Piersall | Thunderbolts | .222 |
| Ed Bailey* | Aces | .220 |
| Rocky Colavito | Blues | .216 |
| Roy McMillan | Arsenal | .211 |
| Bob Speake* | Carp | .205 |
| Milt Bolling | Stampers | .186 |
| Bill Virdon* | Larks | .186 |
| Jim Gilliam# | Aces | .177 |